Select up to four bottles for a detailed side-by-side comparison.
Match all included notes and exclude any avoided notes. Based on the catalog’s listed notes; fragrances without documented notes are excluded when filtering.
AAgarwood (Oud)
AAmber
AAmbroxan
BBenzoin
BBergamot
BBrown sugar
CCade oil
CCaramel
CCashmeran
CCashmere Wood
CCedar
CCedarwood
CChestnut
CClove
CCloves
GGuaiac Wood
GGuaiac Woods
HHerbal Notes
IIncense
JJasmine
JJuniper
LLicorice
MMarshmallow
MMusk
NNutmeg
OOakmoss
OOrange
OOrange Blossom
PPepper
PPeru Balsam
PPink Pepper
SSandalwood
SSugar
VVanilla
WWoodsy Notes
WWoody Notes
9 of 9 documented alternativesAbout scent match & editorial evidence
Estimated scent match. We use the dedicated similarity percentage in a published Chaos clone guide for the exact fragrance edition. The newest matching Clones & Alternatives guide is the source of truth. An approved dupe-of comparison score is used only when no matching clone-guide entry exists, converted from 0–10 to a percentage. We do not generate percentages from guide rank, overall ratings, note overlap or buying recommendations.
Editorial evidence. Strong means an estimate with all three scent topics, or at least two topics plus linked coverage in both Clones & Alternatives and a dupe-of guide. Moderate means two topics, or an estimate with one topic or both linked guides. Limited means less coverage. Linked percentages are counted once. This describes our editorial support, not laboratory accuracy or independent consensus.
Guide order. This follows the Chaos guide covering the most available alternatives for this original, using its explicit ranks or otherwise its displayed order. A guide’s overall ranking can consider value and wearability; the highest-ranked bottle need not have the highest scent-match estimate. Guide position also breaks equal-estimate ties within that guide. Unscored bottles remain available to compare.
General consensus. Automated review checks extracted pages for the exact editions and quoted support. Firsthand comparisons carry more weight; duplicate discussions and authors count once, and each site’s influence is capped. Three distinct comparisons across two sites are required to adjust the score. Explicit resemblance percentages are used when quoted; otherwise very close, close, partial and weak scent comparisons map to 96, 87, 70 and 45 as internal weighting signals, not published reviewer ratings. External influence is at most 25%, reduced for conflicting evidence, with a five-point adjustment cap. Missing Chaos scores stay unscored. Excluded, changed or expired evidence is withdrawn until reviewed again. This adjustment applies only in Clone Lab.
The guide ranks this #6 of 8. Guide order can also reflect value and wearability.
What the editorial covers
Scent differencesAmeer Al Oudh Intense Oud shares By the Fireplace's sweet, smoky, woody direction but does not reproduce its chestnut, clove, orange blossom, Peru balsam, or cashmeran details. It is heavier, sweeter, more oud-forward, and less dry or airy than the reference.Read source ↗
OpeningNot documented
DrydownNot documented
Evidence describes coverage in Chaos guides, not independent testing. Price, commission and shared-note counts do not change the estimate.
Ameer Al Oudh Intense Oud shares By the Fireplace's sweet, smoky, woody direction but does not reproduce its chestnut, clove, orange blossom, Peru balsam, or cashmeran details. It is heavier, sweeter, more oud-forward, and less dry or airy than the reference.
Shared notes
VVanilla (shared with original)
Different listed notes
WWoody Notes
AAgarwood (Oud)
SSugar
Why it appears here
Strong-consensus relationship with a published Chaos comparison.
The guide ranks this #1 of 8. Guide order can also reflect value and wearability.
What the editorial covers
Scent differencesCamp Fire reproduces eight of the nine notes in the current official By the Fireplace pyramid, using juniper where Maison Margiela lists cade oil. It tends to feel sweeter, denser, and less texturally smoky, while the original is airier and more polished around the charred-wood effect.Read source ↗
OpeningNot documented
DrydownNot documented
Evidence describes coverage in Chaos guides, not independent testing. Price, commission and shared-note counts do not change the estimate.
Camp Fire reproduces eight of the nine notes in the current official By the Fireplace pyramid, using juniper where Maison Margiela lists cade oil. It tends to feel sweeter, denser, and less texturally smoky, while the original is airier and more polished around the charred-wood effect.
Shared notes
PPink Pepper (shared with original)
OOrange Blossom (shared with original)
CChestnut (shared with original)
GGuaiac Wood (shared with original)
Different listed notes
CClove
Why it appears here
Strong-consensus relationship with a published Chaos comparison.
The guide ranks this #2 of 8. Guide order can also reflect value and wearability.
What the editorial covers
Scent differencesAce of Spades follows the same eight-note overlap as Camp Fire and likewise substitutes juniper for the original's currently listed cade oil. It is typically smoother and a little less forcefully sweet than Camp Fire, but still lacks some of Maison Margiela's airy smoke, chestnut texture, and refinement.Read source ↗
OpeningNot documented
DrydownNot documented
Evidence describes coverage in Chaos guides, not independent testing. Price, commission and shared-note counts do not change the estimate.
Ace of Spades follows the same eight-note overlap as Camp Fire and likewise substitutes juniper for the original's currently listed cade oil. It is typically smoother and a little less forcefully sweet than Camp Fire, but still lacks some of Maison Margiela's airy smoke, chestnut texture, and refinement.
Shared notes
CCloves (shared with original)
PPink Pepper (shared with original)
OOrange Blossom (shared with original)
CChestnut (shared with original)
Why it appears here
Included in a published Chaos Clones & Alternatives guide.
The guide ranks this #7 of 8. Guide order can also reflect value and wearability.
What the editorial covers
Scent differencesRaghba Wood Intense connects through guaiac wood, cashmere-like woods, vanilla, amber, and smoke, but replaces chestnut, clove, orange blossom, and balsam with caramel, licorice, oud, incense, moss, and musk.Read source ↗
OpeningNot documented
DrydownNot documented
Evidence describes coverage in Chaos guides, not independent testing. Price, commission and shared-note counts do not change the estimate.
Raghba Wood Intense connects through guaiac wood, cashmere-like woods, vanilla, amber, and smoke, but replaces chestnut, clove, orange blossom, and balsam with caramel, licorice, oud, incense, moss, and musk. The result is darker, more resinous, rougher, and more forceful.
Shared notes
GGuaiac Wood (shared with original)
VVanilla (shared with original)
Different listed notes
CCaramel
LLicorice
CCedar
Why it appears here
Included in a published Chaos Clones & Alternatives guide.
The guide ranks this #8 of 8. Guide order can also reflect value and wearability.
What the editorial covers
Scent differencesClub Black shares incense, vanilla, woods, and an amber-balsamic warmth, but it does not contain the chestnut, clove, smoke, or cashmeran structure that defines By the Fireplace. It is smoother, sweeter, more ambery, and less charred.Read source ↗
OpeningNot documented
DrydownNot documented
Evidence describes coverage in Chaos guides, not independent testing. Price, commission and shared-note counts do not change the estimate.
Club Black shares incense, vanilla, woods, and an amber-balsamic warmth, but it does not contain the chestnut, clove, smoke, or cashmeran structure that defines By the Fireplace. It is smoother, sweeter, more ambery, and less charred.
Shared notes
VVanilla (shared with original)
Different listed notes
BBergamot
IIncense
JJasmine
Why it appears here
Included in a published Chaos Clones & Alternatives guide.
Compare the bottle price you will pay with cost per 100 mL. A lower unit price can require a larger purchase. Price alone does not establish scent quality or performance.
Chaos Fragrances may earn a commission when you shop through our links. Prices are in USD, exclude shipping and tax, and can change at checkout. Editorial relationships and rankings are independent of retailer commissions.
WATCH THE COVERAGE
Chaos video reviews
Mapped to this exact fragrance. Each review retains its own publication context.