Start here if you already know what matters most to you.
Afnan Portrait Abstract leads at about 88% resemblance. It follows Encelade’s unusual mix of rhubarb, smoke, leather and woods, with a sweeter, rounder feel. DUA Captivating Nature follows at about 85%, keeping the green, woody character with a rougher finish.
Closest overall match
Afnan Portrait - Abstract
About 88% resemblance. Rhubarb, smoky leather and warmer woods; estimated wear of 8–10 hours.
$35.99
Shop now →
DUA alternative
The Dua Brand Captivating Nature
About 85% resemblance. Green rhubarb over warm woods; 6–8 hours is a brand estimate.
See prices
Shop now →
See the original fragrance profile, notes, performance data and current retailer options.
Encelade puts tart rhubarb against smoky leather and dry, earthy woods. Sandalwood and tonka soften the edges, but that clash between bright greenery and darker warmth is what makes it memorable.
Shop Portrait Abstract at FragranceNet for the closest overall match, or explore Captivating Nature at DUA for another take on the rhubarb-and-wood character.
A fast side-by-side look at similarity, performance, value and who each fragrance suits best.
| Rank | Fragrance | Score | Similarity | Longevity | Best for | Best price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 |
Afnan Portrait - Abstract
|
8.8/10 | 88% | 8–10 hours | Encelade’s rhubarb, smoky leather and woody warmth | $35.99 Shop now |
| #2 |
The Dua Brand Captivating Nature
|
8.5/10 | 85% | 6–8 hours | A green rhubarb-and-wood interpretation | Check price Shop now |
Each pick includes the important differences, tradeoffs and our bottom-line verdict.
Portrait Abstract joins tart rhubarb to incense, leather and warm woods. Tonka and amber round it out, giving the familiar green-and-dark contrast a sweeter feel. Estimated wear is 8–10 hours.
The first pick for a close Encelade alternative, especially if a slightly rounder interpretation sounds appealing.
It is less sharply green than Encelade, with more sweetness and a smokier, creamier feel. The fruity side can suggest cherry rather than crisp rhubarb. That warmer balance changes the effect even when the family resemblance is clear.
Captivating Nature pairs rhubarb and vetiver with sandalwood, cedar and tonka. It follows Encelade’s green, woody direction, with a rich base underneath. The 6–8-hour wear figure is a brand estimate.
A worthwhile DUA option when you want the rhubarb-and-wood character in a smaller extrait bottle.
The overall resemblance is good, but the blend feels less refined. Its weight and strength can be more noticeable than the smooth transitions that make Encelade distinctive.
Resemblance estimates weigh the opening, heart and drydown at 30%, 40% and 30%. The reference is Encelade Eau de Parfum. Wear estimates are 8–10 hours for Portrait Abstract and 6–8 hours for Captivating Nature; the DUA figure is a brand estimate.
Start with Portrait Abstract for the closest overall Encelade alternative. Its warmer sweetness smooths some of the original’s sharp green contrast. Captivating Nature is another good option when the rhubarb and woody warmth are the main draw, though it feels less polished. Encelade itself keeps the most striking balance of tart greenery, smoke and creamy woods.
For other distinctive scent styles, explore our Ganymede clone guide, Tilia clone guide, and Fucking Fabulous clone guide.
Portrait Abstract leads at about 88% resemblance. It captures the rhubarb, smoky leather and woody warmth, with a sweeter and less sharply green balance.
About 85% overall. It keeps the green rhubarb-and-wood direction, but the blend feels less refined than Encelade.
Estimated wear is 8–10 hours. Its darker leather and woody warmth become more prominent as it settles.
The brand estimate is 6–8 hours. That figure is separate from its resemblance score.
Tart rhubarb meets smoky leather, cedar and earthy vetiver, with creamy sandalwood and tonka adding warmth.
It is rounder and sweeter. Encelade keeps a sharper contrast between the green opening and darker leather-and-wood character.
Its fruity tartness, tonka and darker notes can create that impression. Cherry is not a listed note in the fragrance.
Yes. Incense and leather give it a darker side, and the smoke can feel more prominent than in Encelade.
No. It is DUA’s single-inspiration interpretation of Encelade, centered on rhubarb, vetiver, sandalwood, tonka and cedar.
Yes. Encelade, Portrait Abstract and Captivating Nature are presented as unisex fragrances. The choice comes down to how much tart greenery, smoke and woody warmth you enjoy.
Mild or cooler weather gives their green notes and warmer base room to sit together. The smoky, leathery side also suits evenings.
When its sharp green contrast and smoother development are the main attraction. Both alternatives approach the character, but neither keeps every detail of that balance.
Shopping links are affiliate links; purchases may earn Chaos Fragrances a commission.
