My collection
Chaos Fragrances buying guide

The Best Dior Poison EDT Dupes & Alternatives

Compare Lomani Elitis EDT and Fred Hayman 273 EDP for their connection to original Dior Poison, scent differences, numerical longevity and shopping options.
Independently ranked by the Chaos Fragrances editorial team
#1 Closer plum-and-tuberose direction Elitis EDT $10.95
Shop best price at FragranceShop Compare every pick →
The original vs. the alternatives Which bottle gets closest?
The reference Dior Poison fragrance bottle Dior Poison #1 Closer plum-and-tuberose direction Lomani Elitis EDT fragrance bottle Elitis EDT
Fred Hayman 273 EDP fragrance bottle #2Fred Hayman 273 EDP
01 / The shortlist

The quick picks

Start here if you already know what matters most to you.

Quick answer

Lomani Elitis EDT is our first Poison-style alternative to sample, at approximately 80% resemblance. Its plum and tuberose provide the more direct connection. Fred Hayman 273 Rodeo Drive EDP is a broader alternative at approximately 72%, shifting toward peach, gardenia and a softer floral-woody finish.

Lomani Elitis EDT fragrance bottle Closer plum-and-tuberose direction Elitis EDT Approximately 80% resemblance, with a lighter, fruitier interpretation of the Poison connection. $10.95 Shop now → Fred Hayman 273 EDP fragrance bottle Peachier floral alternative Fred Hayman 273 EDP Approximately 72% resemblance; a broader tuberose, gardenia and warm-woods direction. $22.67 Shop now →
Dior Poison fragrance bottle
The reference fragrance

Dior Poison

See the original fragrance profile, notes, performance data and current retailer options.

$108.66 View fragrance & prices →

Original Dior Poison combines dark fruit, spiced white flowers and a warm balsamic finish. Its plum-and-tuberose character is the starting point here. This guide targets Poison Eau de Toilette, the original fragrance family introduced in 1985. Hypnotic Poison, Pure Poison, Tendre Poison, Midnight Poison and Poison Girl are separate fragrances.

Start with Lomani Elitis EDT at Jomashop for the closer plum-and-tuberose direction. For a broader, peachier floral alternative, check Fred Hayman 273 EDP at FragranceNet. Confirm the selected concentration, bottle size, stock and final checkout total.

Vintage Poison and today’s EDT can smell different, and many comparisons draw on older bottles. These are alternatives to sample for a recognizable connection, not a promise to recreate every Poison formulation.

02 / Compare

Compare the best options

A fast side-by-side look at similarity, performance, value and who each fragrance suits best.

Rank Fragrance Score Similarity Longevity Best for Best price
#1 Elitis EDT 8/10 80% 5–6 hours Poison’s fruity tuberose character with less smoky depth $10.95 Shop now
#2 Fred Hayman 273 EDP 7.5/10 72% Around 4 hours a broader tuberose-and-gardenia scent with warm fruit and woods $22.67 Shop now
03 / Reviews

The full ranking

Each pick includes the important differences, tradeoffs and our bottom-line verdict.

#1 Lomani Elitis EDT fragrance bottle
Closer plum-and-tuberose direction Best for Poison’s fruity tuberose character with less smoky depth
Lomani

Elitis EDT

Elitis EDT is the more direct option for Poison’s plum-and-tuberose connection. Peach, raspberry and a warm floral heart make it a fruitier interpretation, with less of the original’s dark, smoky complexity.

Best tracked price $10.95
Shop best price at FragranceShop Compare prices & details
The preferred Jomashop listing is the regular women’s Elitis EDT spray, advertised as 3.33 oz, barcode 3610400000370. The pictured presentation is marked 100 ml; confirm the retailer’s selected bottle and stated volume at checkout.
Chaos score 8/10
Similarity 80%
Longevity 5–6 hours
Chaos verdict

Start here for the closer connection, while allowing for a different finish. Use 5–6 hours as a planning estimate from one explicit total-wear account. Shorter wear is possible; a strong first spray does not establish all-day performance.

How it differs from the original

The opening can recall older Poison EDT especially well, but the later scent is lighter and less densely balsamic. The incense and complex berry-and-wood effect are reduced. Its sweeter floral character can also feel like an independent perfume rather than a direct replacement.

What works
  • The stronger plum-and-tuberose connection on this shortlist
  • A fruitier and less smoky take on the theme
  • An exact preferred-retailer EDT listing
Tradeoffs
  • The base is lighter and less complex than Poison
  • Vintage associations do not guarantee a match to current EDT
  • The numerical wear estimate comes from one timed account
#2 Fred Hayman 273 EDP fragrance bottle
Peachier floral alternative Best for a broader tuberose-and-gardenia scent with warm fruit and woods
Fred Hayman

Fred Hayman 273 EDP

273 Rodeo Drive EDP shares a rich floral-and-fruit connection while leaning into peach, gardenia and tuberose. Its warmer floral character makes sense as an alternative with a personality of its own.

Best tracked price $22.67
Shop best price at FragranceNet Compare prices & details
The preferred FragranceNet destination selects the women’s 273 EDP spray 2.5 oz, item 122151. The men’s 273 cologne, 273 Red and 273 Indigo are separate fragrances. Confirm the selected size and presentation.
Chaos score 7.5/10
Similarity 72%
Longevity Around 4 hours
Chaos verdict

Choose 273 for the fuller, peachier floral variation. Around 4 hours is a qualified planning estimate from one explicitly timed EDP wearing, not an average or a maximum. Its bold opening should not be mistaken for guaranteed long wear.

How it differs from the original

Peach and gardenia change the balance, and the later fragrance can become softer and less closely connected to Poison. The opening may suggest the same era before the two move apart. It is a broader alternative, especially when a dark plum-and-incense effect is essential to you.

What works
  • A rich floral direction with a recognizable Poison connection
  • Peach and gardenia offer a distinct variation
  • Existing FragranceNet and Jomashop shopping options
Tradeoffs
  • Resemblance can weaken after the opening
  • Gardenia and peach may overshadow the darker fruit effect
  • The numerical wear estimate is based on one timed EDP wearing
04 / Our process

How we chose these fragrances

We assess perceived resemblance through the opening, heart and drydown, weighted 30%, 40% and 30%. Comparisons by wearers familiar with Poison carry more weight than note overlap or inspiration claims. Percentages are editorial estimates, not ingredient measurements or a controlled wearing test. Overall scores also consider character, wearability and purchase options.

We distinguish current EDT from vintage Poison and other concentrations. Several of the strongest scent comparisons involve older EDT bottles; that connection does not establish an exact match to today’s spray.

Elitis’s 5–6 hours planning range follows one explicitly timed total-wear account; shorter results also occur. For 273 EDP, Around 4 hours is a qualified estimate from one explicitly timed EDP wearing, rather than a multi-wear average or an upper limit. Quiet skin presence counts as wear. Projection, clothes persistence, reapplication schedules and a still-detectable check-in do not establish total-wear endpoints.

The final verdict

Sample Elitis EDT first if Poison’s plum-and-tuberose connection is what you want. Choose 273 Rodeo Drive EDP when a peachier, fuller floral variation sounds appealing. Compare either through its settled heart and finish. Keep the original in contention when its particular spice, honeyed flowers and balsamic depth matter most, especially if you are trying to replace a specific older bottle.

For different fragrance directions, explore our Hypnotic Poison dupe guide, Shalimar EDP dupe guide, and Mugler Angel dupe guide. Each targets a different original.

05 / Questions

Frequently asked questions

What is the closest Dior Poison alternative here?

Lomani Elitis EDT is our first candidate to sample, at approximately 80% resemblance. Its plum-and-tuberose connection is more direct than 273 Rodeo Drive’s broader floral variation.

Is Elitis an exact clone of Poison?

No. It can recall Poison’s fruity floral character, particularly older EDT bottles, but has less smoky complexity and a lighter base. Compare the full wearing rather than the first spray alone.

How close is Fred Hayman 273 to Poison?

We estimate approximately 72% resemblance. It is a broader alternative, with peach and gardenia changing the balance and a softer floral-woody finish that can move away from Poison.

Does this guide cover Hypnotic Poison or Pure Poison?

No. It targets original Poison EDT. Hypnotic Poison, Pure Poison, Tendre Poison, Midnight Poison and Poison Girl require separate comparisons.

Will these recreate vintage Poison?

Neither is a guaranteed replacement for a particular vintage bottle. Older EDT comparisons help identify the scent connection, but age, formulation and concentration can affect what you recognize.

How long does Elitis EDT last?

Use 5–6 hours as a planning estimate from one explicit timed total wearing. Shorter results also occur, and skin presence can become quiet before the fragrance disappears.

How long does 273 Rodeo Drive EDP last?

Around 4 hours is a qualified estimate from one explicitly timed EDP wearing. It is not a multi-wear average or an upper limit; individual results can vary substantially.

Which one is fruitier?

Elitis is the starting point for a plum-led fruity floral direction. 273 moves toward peach and apricot around a fuller white-floral character. Neither reproduces every aspect of Poison’s dark fruit.

Which concentrations should I buy?

Select Elitis Eau de Toilette and the women’s 273 Eau de Parfum discussed here. Concentration names alone do not determine resemblance or how long a scent will last.

Is 273 for men the same perfume?

No. The candidate here is women’s 273 Rodeo Drive EDP, including the reviewed FragranceNet 2.5 oz spray, item 122151. Men’s 273, 273 Red and 273 Indigo are different fragrances.

Are these easy choices for a crowded office?

Both have a rich floral character that can feel prominent at first. Start with a light application, let it settle and assess it in your own space before wearing it close to colleagues.

When should I choose original Poison EDT instead?

Choose the original when its particular spice, honeyed tuberose and balsamic depth are central to what you love. Sample a current EDT bottle if your reference is a vintage version.

This guide contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Check the retailer for current stock, bottle size, presentation, shipping and final price.