Creed Carmina combines black cherry, saffron, rich rose and warm woody resins.
DUA The Poem is our closest overall Carmina pick, with a bold rose-led character and softer incense. ALT Melodia takes a fruitier, sweeter floral route.
Start here if you already know what matters most to you.
DUA The Poem is our closest overall Carmina pick, with a bold rose-led character and softer incense. ALT Melodia takes a fruitier, sweeter floral route.
See the original fragrance profile, notes, performance data and current retailer options.
Creed Carmina combines black cherry, saffron, rich rose and warm woody resins.
DUA The Poem is our closest overall Carmina pick, with a bold rose-led character and softer incense. ALT Melodia takes a fruitier, sweeter floral route.
A fast side-by-side look at similarity, performance, value and who each fragrance suits best.
| Rank | Fragrance | Score | Similarity | Longevity | Best for | Best price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 |
|
9.3/10 | 92% | 4–6 hours | bold rose with warm resinous depth | Check price Shop now |
| #2 |
|
9.1/10 | 89% | 6+ hours | sweet fruit, rose and soft powder | Check price Shop now |
Each pick includes the important differences, tradeoffs and our bottom-line verdict.
Black cherry and pink pepper meet rose, violet and peony over soft woods, amber and musk.
Start with The Poem for the closest overall Carmina direction. One timed wearing ran 4–6 hours.
The Poem stays close to Carmina’s rich rose-and-fruit character. It can put rose farther forward and soften the incense, with cherry and resins less obvious at first. The settled scent is warm and musky, with a bold floral presence.
Warm spices lead into rose, tuberose and orris, with amber, musk and vanilla in the finish.
Choose Melodia for a fruitier, sweeter floral take. One wearing reached six hours before reapplication.
Melodia keeps Carmina’s lush floral impression, but can feel fruitier, sweeter and a little less refined. The powdery flowers are more obvious on some skin.
We compare the opening, heart and drydown, giving the heart the most weight. Rankings also consider texture, wear and value. Similarity percentages are editorial estimates. Wear windows include the quiet finish and vary with skin and application. The Poem’s 4–6 hours reflects one timed wearing. Melodia’s 6+ hours is an observed minimum before reapplication, not a fixed endpoint.
DUA The Poem is our closest overall Carmina pick, with a bold rose-led character and softer incense. ALT Melodia takes a fruitier, sweeter floral route. Choose The Poem for the closer overall balance, or Melodia if you prefer more fruit and powdery flowers.
Explore our Creed Queen of Silk dupe guide, Parfums de Marly Delina dupe guide, and Parfums de Marly Delina Exclusif dupe guide.
DUA The Poem is our closest overall pick. ALT Melodia takes a fruitier and sweeter route.
One timed wearing ran 4–6 hours. That is an observed range, rather than a fixed result for every wearer.
One wearing reached six hours before the wearer reapplied. The 6+ figure is an observed minimum, not a total wear-time endpoint.
It can emphasize rose and soften the incense, with the fruit and resins less obvious at first.
It can feel fruitier, sweeter and more powdery, with a less restrained balance.
The Poem is the first sample for a strong rose-led impression.
Melodia has the more noticeable fruity effect in the comparisons reviewed here.
Its sweet fruit is framed by spices, lush flowers, powder and a warm musky finish.
It is DUA’s direct Carmina interpretation, rather than an Aventus hybrid.
Carmina is the reference. A shared rich floral mood does not make these the same fragrance as Delina.
Black cherry and saffron open into rich rose and warm woody resins, with amber and musk softness.
Start with The Poem for overall resemblance, or Melodia for sweeter fruit and powdery flowers.
Chaos Fragrances may earn a commission through these shopping links. Our rankings are independent.